Have I ever told you about my magic sauce?
I really don’t think I have. So I am going to tell you now.
It is magic for three reasons:
1. It is easy.
2. It is quick.
3. It makes pretty much ANYTHING taste better.
You are suspicious, I can tell.
So please, allow me to prove my points with very scientific, um, proofs.
1. It is easy.
First of all, the Magic Sauce has only four ingredients. And it requires only three kitchen items. Well, three items and a stove. And all of the kitchen items and ingredients are likely to be kitchen items and ingredients that you already have. AND you don’t have to really measure the ingredients, because you use equal parts of all four of them! Which means you ALSO don’t need to use a recipe! AND once you turn on the stove, you don’t really need to do anything except give it a stir once in a while! Really! It cooks itself just fine and dandy!
See? EASY.
2. It is quick.
The Magic Sauce takes about 10 minutes, from Combining Ingredients to Done.
And I am being 100% honest here. Because I hate when you find a recipe that says, “This takes 10 minutes to prepare and 30 minutes to cook!” and then that 10 minutes is supposed to be enough time for you to wash and chop AND measure AND combine ingredients.
But this Magic Sauce is just dumping equal parts of four ingredients into a saucepan. And turning on the stove. And stirring, if you feel like it.
3. It makes pretty much ANYTHING better.
Now, I have not tried the Magic Sauce on EVERYTHING. Partly because that would be impossible and partly because there are some foods I just won’t eat.
But I HAVE tried it on several things.
It is delicious on:
- Broiled salmon (I season the salmon with salt, pepper, and cayenne and throw it under the broiler until the Magic Sauce is done. This makes for some crispy ass salmon, but I tend to like meats overcooked.)

Please do not judge the Magic Sauce on this poorly photographed image of broiled salmon slathered in Magic Sauce. What it lacks in beauty, it more than makes up for in deliciousness. Also, I think this may be a case of "just because you have a photo of the Magic Sauce doesn't mean you should include it." But I have spent too much time writing this caption to listen to that advice.
- Baked potato
- Endive appetizers (You take some Belgian endive leaves – those are the little white pointy endives with the yellow tips – and fill them with some dried cranberries, toasted pecans/walnuts, and goat cheese crumbles, and then drizzle them with not-super-hot Magic Sauce.)
- Grilled chicken
- Pan fried pork chops
- Ice cream (bet you didn’t see that one coming!) (I have only tried Magic Sauce on vanilla ice cream, but I think it would be good on lemon ice cream, or raspberry, or chocolate. Or goat cheese ice cream. Have you ever had that? It is GOOD. Well, if you already like goat cheese.)
I also suspect – based on my copious Magic Sauce-eating experience – that it would taste good on several other foods. Like sautéed/grilled/roasted asparagus. Or Brussels sprouts. Or chocolate cake. Or fresh fruit (like strawberries, blueberries, or peaches). Or swordfish.
Now you want the recipe, don’t you?
Here it is:
Step 1: Combine equal parts brown sugar, balsamic vinegar, lemon juice, and water in a medium saucepan. (I usually use ½ cup of each.) (Make sure you don’t fill the sauce pan too full, as there is some bubbling involved.)
Step 2: Stir until dissolved. Or don’t. It doesn’t really matter.
Step 3: Turn the burner on high.
Step 4: Wait until the Magic Sauce has transformed from Extremely Liquid-y to Thick And Sauce-Like. (It will bubble a LOT to get to that point. The bubbles will get increasingly sticky.) You will know the sauce is perfect when it is your ideal thickness. This takes about eight minutes, at least with my stove.
Step 5: Drown Pour over whatever food you want to enhance. Seriously.
You can save the Magic Sauce, if you have any leftover. But… It gets a bit, well, unusable. I have not yet figured out how to reheat it in a satisfactory manner.
Aside from its un-save-ability, there is one drawback to the Magic Sauce. I don’t actually find it a drawback, but my husband does. So in the interest of full disclosure, I feel that I must share it with you.
Anyway, when the Magic Sauce is bubbling away, it gives off a very strong Vinegar Aroma. This aroma does not bother me. But it offends my husband’s delicate nostrils, so much so that he groans loudly if I want to make the Magic Sauce in his presence.
The aroma dissipates quickly, though. So if I make Magic Sauce while my husband is working late, he doesn’t come home and wrinkle his nose in Nostril Offense.
Well! That is my Magic Sauce. Go forth and sauce it up! And then please report back with your results.

I will definitely try this. It sounds really good. However, Matt will also complain about the vinegar smell, so I will make it before he gets home.
hmm I’m totally going to make this SOON. Like, the next time I have Salmon…which will probably be this weekend. You’re right…it does look kinda scary, but I trust your good judgment! Magic Sauce here I come!
The recipe sounds kind of like a bar-b-que sauce (not the super sweet kind you get from the store or restaurants (which are tomato based), but the vinegar based kind.)
I see what you mean, but it’s definitely more of a deepened balsamic vinegar flavor than anything BBQ-sauce related.
I love vinegar! This sounds very interesting.
Based on the title of this post, it could have gone in so many different directions
But I’m totally trying this, it sounds wonderful!
My husband – since I shouldn’t be allowed within fifty yards of a kitchen – does something similar! I would eat this on anything at any time, even if it didn’t necessarily go with it. I’m not fussy. I have a deep and abiding love for balsamic vinegar thanks to this sauce.
Whoa whoa whoa. Hang on. Is there really such a thing as goat cheese ice cream?! Like actually made from goat’s milk? If this is the case, I’m going to need brand names/locations to purchase, because goat’s milk is the only kind of milk I can tolerate, and let’s face it – “Rice Dream Ice Cream” simply does not cut it!
Umm…right…what was this post about? Oh yes, magical sauce. I’m intrigued by it and just might have to try it. Balsamic is one of my faves. Does it take forever to clean out of the pan? I dislike gooey pans.
RE: Goat cheese ice cream: I think, unfortunately, it is made with goat cheese but also with regular milk. The kind I’ve had is Jeni’s (http://jenisicecreams.com/) and it’s delicious.
RE: Clean up: NO – this is not sticky or messy at all! You just put the pan in hot water and all the leftover sauce (if there is any) just dissolves away. Super easy.
I can’t wait to try this! It looks AMAZING. I WANT IT
I think I may be a WEEE BIT obsessed with capitals…
Ohhhhh that looks good! And I am definitely going to need to try that
I love me a versatile sauce that I can put on anything. And it seems as though this might just do the trick!
Honestly, I was totally afraid you were going to say something like, “Oh my gosh, this is magicsauce.” You know, like when people say ridiculous things like, “That’s awesomesauce.” I was worried that we couldn’t be friends anymore. THEN, I realized that you were going to enhance my culinary skillz (had to throw that in) and all was forgiven! ha, yah, I want to try that. Is this balsamic reduction?
Oh, I am in love with anything balsamic vinegar, so I’m pretty sure this would be perfect. Never thought to try it on baked potatoes! Interesting.
I love balsamic and I love vinegar – can’t wait to try this! Thanks for sharing – I was just posting this morning about how “over it” I am feeling about my go-to recipes lately.
This sounds amazing! Thanks for sharing your recipe. I can’t wait to try it!
I think I tweeted that I was going to make this last week and then I changed course menu-wise, but I’m making it tonight! Very excited, will report back.
I am definitely going to try this! Especially on ice cream… that just sounds too interesting to pass up. Thanks for sharing